Is AFG or ERIE cheaper?

On trailing earnings, AFG is cheaper: AFG trades at a 13.20 P/E and ERIE at 21.96.

Which has grown faster, AFG or ERIE?

Over the past five years, ERIE grew revenue faster — AFG at a 3.20% CAGR versus ERIE at 9.91%.

Does AFG or ERIE pay a bigger dividend?

AFG yields 2.53% and ERIE yields 2.45% based on trailing dividends and the latest price.

Is AFG or ERIE more profitable?

ERIE runs the higher net margin — AFG at 10.78% versus ERIE at 13.97%.

Which has been the better investment, AFG or ERIE?

Over the past 10-year, AFG delivered the higher annualized total return — AFG at 12.73% versus ERIE at 11.87%. Past performance doesn't predict future results.

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) vs Erie Indemnity Company (ERIE)

AFG and ERIE are evenly matched — 7 metrics each of 14.

A side-by-side comparison of American Financial Group, Inc. and Erie Indemnity Company across valuation, profitability, dividends, and growth — built entirely from reported fundamentals, as of June 28, 2026. The ● marks the stronger figure on each row (cheaper multiple, higher margin/return).

AFG

American Financial Group, Inc.

$11.56B

$139.18Financial Services

ERIE

Erie Indemnity Company

$11.03B

$238.71Financial Services

Total return — AFG vs ERIE

growth of $100 · last 30y

AFG +593.1%ERIE +430.5%AFG compounded faster

AFG ERIE

AFG vs ERIE: by the numbers

•AFG is the larger company ($11.56B vs $11.03B market cap).
•AFG trades at the lower earnings multiple (13.20 vs 21.96 P/E).
•ERIE converts more revenue to profit (13.97% vs 10.78% net margin).
•ERIE grew revenue faster over the past five years (9.91% vs 3.20% CAGR).
•AFG pays the higher dividend yield (2.53% vs 2.45%).

Which is better, AFG or ERIE?

Metric tally: AFG 7 · ERIE 7

It depends on what you're optimizing for:

ValueAFG(lower P/E)

GrowthERIE(faster 5Y revenue CAGR)

IncomeAFG(higher dividend yield)

QualityERIE(higher ROIC)

Metrics side by side

Valuation

Metric	AFG	ERIE
P/E ratio	13.20●	21.96
Forward P/E	11.93●	18.86
P/S ratio	1.42●	3.07
P/B ratio	2.48●	5.34
PEG ratio	3.28	1.59●

Profitability

Metric	AFG	ERIE
Gross margin	46.32%●	16.12%
Operating margin	13.68%	17.94%●
Net margin	10.78%	13.97%●
ROE	18.79%	24.28%●
ROIC	9.67%	23.22%●

Dividends

Metric	AFG	ERIE
Dividend yield	2.53%●	2.45%
Payout ratio	35.02%	48.71%

Growth (annualized)

Metric	AFG	ERIE
Revenue CAGR (5Y)	3.20%	9.91%●
EPS CAGR (5Y)	4.03%	13.78%●
Total return CAGR (5Y)	8.80%●	6.21%

Frequently asked

Which is better, AFG or ERIE?: It depends on your goal. value: AFG (lower P/E); growth: ERIE (faster 5Y revenue CAGR); income: AFG (higher dividend yield); quality: ERIE (higher ROIC). Across all compared metrics, they are evenly matched.
Is AFG or ERIE cheaper?: On trailing earnings, AFG is cheaper: AFG trades at a 13.20 P/E and ERIE at 21.96.
Which has grown faster, AFG or ERIE?: Over the past five years, ERIE grew revenue faster — AFG at a 3.20% CAGR versus ERIE at 9.91%.
Does AFG or ERIE pay a bigger dividend?: AFG yields 2.53% and ERIE yields 2.45% based on trailing dividends and the latest price.
Is AFG or ERIE more profitable?: ERIE runs the higher net margin — AFG at 10.78% versus ERIE at 13.97%.
Which has been the better investment, AFG or ERIE?: Over the past 10-year, AFG delivered the higher annualized total return — AFG at 12.73% versus ERIE at 11.87%. Past performance doesn't predict future results.

Go deeper

Full AFG analysis Full ERIE analysis Interactive comparison tool

Dig into the metrics

American Financial P/E ratio Erie Indemnity P/E ratio American Financial dividend yield Erie Indemnity dividend yield American Financial ROE Erie Indemnity ROE American Financial operating margin Erie Indemnity operating margin American Financial revenue growth Erie Indemnity revenue growth American Financial free cash flow Erie Indemnity free cash flow

American Financial & Erie Indemnity appear in these rankings

Highest Dividend Yield Stocks Highest ROIC Stocks Highest FCF Yield Stocks Lowest P/E Ratio Stocks

Figures are sourced from reported fundamentals and the latest end-of-day price. This comparison is informational only and is not investment advice. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology. Compiled by TGMCharts Research · data verified June 28, 2026.