Casey's General Stores, Inc. (CASY) Earnings Review
Casey's General Stores, Inc. earnings review — the reported quarter's EPS and revenue against the Street's estimates, the forward outlook, margins, cash flow, and valuation reset as of September 9, 2026.
By TGMCharts Research · Data as of · Updated
Casey's General Stores, Inc. posted EPS of $7.37 versus the $6.82 consensus (a 8.09% surprise) on revenue of $5.68B; whether it changed the thesis depends on the forward setup, not the headline.
The review ties the print to the durable trend: the TTM revenue change is 13.78%, operating margin is 3.90%, and the market pays 35.33x trailing earnings; next-quarter consensus is $6.34 EPS.
- Casey's General Stores, Inc. posted EPS of $7.37 versus the $6.82 consensus — a surprise of 8.09%.
- Revenue was $5.68B against a $5.56B estimate — a revenue surprise of 2.11%.
- Trailing-twelve-month revenue change is 13.78% and EPS change is 33.25%.
- Operating margin is 3.90% and net margin is 4.14%.
- Next quarter consensus is $6.34 EPS on $5.35B revenue, with the next report due December 8, 2026.
Quarterly Setup
The reported quarter against the Street's estimates, plus the latest TTM trend behind it.
The Read
Casey's General Stores, Inc. has reported, and this is the earnings review: what the quarter delivered against the Street's expectations, and what it means for the underlying business. Actual EPS landed at $7.37 against the $6.82 consensus — a surprise of 8.09% — on revenue of $5.68B versus a $5.56B estimate.
An earnings print only matters if it connects to the durable trend. The trailing-twelve-month revenue change is 13.78% while the TTM EPS change is 33.25%, so the rest of this review tests whether the quarter reinforced that direction across cash flow, margins, and the forward setup rather than simply clearing a bar.
Current compounder snapshot · CASY
Live supporting context; not part of the article's frozen 2026-09-09 evidence snapshot.
- Score
- 28/100
- 10Y CAGR
- 9.4%
- Median YoY
- 10.3%
- YoY volatility
- σ 17.7pp· uneven
- Quarters ≥ 20%
- 9 of 40
- Negative quarters
- 11
- Valuation vs own 10Y history
- P/S 1.5x · 10Y median 0.7x · 94th percentile · as of Sep 8, 2026
How this score is computed
- Quarters at or above 20%: 9 of 40 → 9 of 40 pts
- Steadiness (typical swing 17.7pp) → 12.4 of 25 pts
- Pace (median 10.3% YoY) → 0 of 20 pts
- Latest quarter (24.3% YoY) → 7 of 15 pts
- Score: 28 of 100
Annualized revenue (TTM) · by quarter, last 40
Quarterly YoY revenue growth vs the 20% line
P/S multiple vs its 10Y median
The Quarter Reported
Start with the scorecard. Casey's General Stores, Inc. posted EPS of $7.37 against the $6.82 analysts modeled, an EPS surprise of 8.09%, while revenue of $5.68B compared with the $5.56B consensus for a revenue surprise of 2.11%.
The two surprises together say more than either alone, because a revenue-led result is more durable than one carried by a tax item or a share-count effect on EPS. This section treats the print as a data point about execution against expectations; whether it changed the thesis is decided by the trend lines and the forward outlook below.
Earnings scorecard: reported vs expected
The quarter's actual EPS and revenue against the Street's consensus, with the forward-quarter setup.
CASY TTM revenue Chart
TTM revenue keeps the quarterly review focused on the most recent four-quarter business base. Historical series through 2026-07-31.
Latest revenue TTM growth: 13.78%.
Revenue TTM growth of 13.78% is the first quarterly-review checkpoint. It shows whether the latest reported periods are still adding to the business base.
Revenue And Earnings Direction
The TTM revenue change of 13.78% is most useful beside the net income change of 32.86%. When sales and earnings move apart, the review shifts from a growth story to a margin story. The EPS change of 33.25% then shows what the latest reporting cycle actually delivered per share after buybacks and mix.
CASY TTM net income Chart
Net income TTM history checks whether revenue momentum is reaching the bottom line. Historical series through 2026-07-31.
Latest net income TTM growth: 32.86%.
Net income TTM growth of 32.86% is the earnings-conversion check. If it diverges from revenue growth, the review should focus on margins rather than only sales.
CASY EPS Chart
EPS connects reported earnings momentum to the per-share outcome. Historical series through 2026-04-30.
Latest EPS TTM growth: 33.25%.
EPS TTM growth of 33.25% shows what the recent reporting cycle delivered per share. It is most useful beside revenue and margin data, not as a standalone verdict.
Cash Flow Conversion
Cash conversion is the honesty check on the earnings line. The free-cash-flow change of -2.59% either confirms the EPS result or challenges it, and an earnings review is incomplete when it reports a beat or miss without asking whether cash generation moved the same way.
CASY TTM free cash flow Chart
Free cash flow TTM is the cash-conversion counterpoint to earnings momentum. Historical series through 2026-07-31.
Latest FCF TTM growth: -2.59%.
Free-cash-flow TTM growth of -2.59% can confirm or challenge the earnings story. A quarterly review is incomplete if cash conversion is moving differently from EPS.
Margin Quality
Margin quality decides whether the revenue base is becoming more profitable. Operating margin is 3.90%, gross margin is 17.77%, and net margin is 4.14%. The margin chart belongs here because this is the section that explains why earnings can diverge from sales after a print.
CASY operating margin
Operating margin shows whether the latest revenue base is becoming more or less profitable. Quarter ended Jul 2026 (2026-07-31): 0.00%.
Operating margin (TTM): 3.90%. The bars below are individual quarters, so the latest bar can differ from this trailing-twelve-month figure.
Operating margin (TTM) of 3.90% is the quality read across the last four quarters. The review should become more cautious if growth is present but margin quality is fading.
Forward Outlook
The market trades on the next quarter, not the last one. Consensus models $6.34 in EPS and $5.35B in revenue for the coming quarter, with the next report due December 8, 2026. The forward setup is what turns a backward-looking print into a thesis: a result paired with a soft forward bar reads very differently from one paired with a rising one.
Comparing the just-reported quarter against that forward estimate is one way to test whether expectations are catching up to the business or running ahead of it. The TTM revenue change of 13.78% is the reference point; estimate uncertainty and reporting-basis differences remain limitations.
Valuation Reset
Valuation resets with every print. The market is paying 35.33x trailing earnings and the free-cash-flow yield is 2.38%. A quarter matters most when the valuation has not already priced every improvement in advance, so the multiple is the lens that decides how much the surprise should move the view.
CASY P/E ratio Chart
P/E history keeps the quarterly review connected to what investors are paying for the updated fundamentals. Historical series through 2026-09-08.
Latest P/E ratio: 35.33x.
The P/E ratio at 35.33x is the market's price on the quarterly evidence. Improving fundamentals matter more when the multiple does not already assume too much progress.
Bull/Bear Case
The bull case is that revenue, earnings, cash flow, and margins moved together this quarter while the valuation at 35.33x remains explainable against the forward setup. The bear case is a split between reported earnings and cash generation, or a forward bar that asks too much of the next print. The case work sits before the final read so the review does not end as a recap.
Bull and bear case
Quarterly support
- Revenue TTM growth of 13.78% supports the latest operating momentum.
- Net margin of 4.14% keeps the quarterly review connected to earnings quality.
Quarterly pressure
- Free-cash-flow TTM growth of -2.59% can weaken the read if cash conversion lags earnings.
- The valuation still has to be checked against a P/E ratio of 35.33x.
Final Read
The earnings review is useful only when the print, the trend lines, cash conversion, margin quality, the forward outlook, and the valuation reset tell a coherent story. The source snapshot is dated September 9, 2026. This TGMCharts Research note uses reported fundamentals, linked source pages, and chart exhibits only — a structured read on the reported quarter, not a forecast or personalized investment advice.
FAQ
Did CASY beat or miss earnings estimates last quarter?
Casey's General Stores, Inc. posted EPS of $7.37 against the $6.82 consensus — an EPS surprise of 8.09% — on revenue of $5.68B versus the $5.56B estimate, a revenue surprise of 2.11%.
What is the forward outlook for CASY after the print?
Consensus models $6.34 in EPS on $5.35B in revenue for the coming quarter, with the next report due December 8, 2026. The TTM revenue change of 13.78% is the reference for judging whether that bar is conservative or demanding.
What would make this CASY earnings review stale?
If the next data update materially changes the reported-quarter figures, forward estimates, margins, or valuation inputs, this note is corrected or withdrawn rather than left stale. Figures are as of September 9, 2026.
What would change our mind
- The next report due December 8, 2026 versus the $6.34 EPS consensus.
- Free-cash-flow TTM change versus the EPS TTM change of 33.25%.
- Operating margin or valuation moving away from 3.90% and 35.33x.
The bottom line
Casey's General Stores, Inc. earnings-report review from TGMCharts Research: the reported quarter versus consensus, the forward setup, and what it means for the business — every figure checked against the company's reported data.
Read next: CASY fundamentalsContinue with Casey's General Stores, Inc.'s full stock page.How we checked this researchShowHide
Data snapshot · By TGMCharts Research.
Every number in this note comes from data we compute and store ourselves from the company's reported figures, plus verbatim excerpts from its SEC filings. When a value isn't available we say so — we never fill gaps with estimates.
Latest filing excerpt
10-Q · filed 2026-09-08 · period 2026-07-31 · SEC EDGAR source
- “Grocery and general merchandise revenue increased by $59,578 (4.9%), due to an increase in same-store sales of 2.7% driven by sales of non-alcoholic beverages, as well as an increase of approximately 2.2% related to store growth.”
- “Other revenue increased $26,367 (17.6%) for the first quarter of fiscal 2027 compared to the prior year, driven primarily by an increase in wholesale fuel revenue, largely driven by an increase in the average fuel price per gallon.”
- “Operating expenses increased $55,935 (8.0%) to $754,111 in the first quarter of fiscal 2027.”
- “Depreciation and amortization expense increased $7,031 (6.5%) to $115,994 in the first quarter of fiscal 2027, primarily due to purchases of property and equipment since the comparable period.”
Source pages
Exhibit sources
Research trail
Every number, checked
Every numeric or dated claim in this note was checked against our stored company data before publishing — each figure below links to the page it comes from.