Is ATI or PAYX cheaper?

On trailing earnings, PAYX is cheaper: ATI trades at a 65.72 P/E and PAYX at 22.21.

Which has grown faster, ATI or PAYX?

Over the past five years, PAYX grew revenue faster — ATI at a 8.60% CAGR versus PAYX at 9.95%.

Does ATI or PAYX pay a bigger dividend?

PAYX pays a dividend (4.40% yield) while ATI does not currently pay one.

Is ATI or PAYX more profitable?

PAYX runs the higher net margin — ATI at 9.26% versus PAYX at 25.84%.

Which has been the better investment, ATI or PAYX?

Over the past 10-year, ATI delivered the higher annualized total return — ATI at 30.94% versus PAYX at 9.63%. Past performance doesn't predict future results.

ATI Inc. (ATI) vs Paychex, Inc. (PAYX)

PAYX leads on 14 of 16 compared metrics.

A side-by-side comparison of ATI Inc. and Paychex, Inc. across valuation, profitability, dividends, and growth — built entirely from reported fundamentals, as of June 14, 2026. The ● marks the stronger figure on each row (cheaper multiple, higher margin/return).

Total return — ATI vs PAYX

growth of $100 · last 27y

ATI +686.1%PAYX +283.9%ATI compounded faster

ATI PAYX

ATI vs PAYX: by the numbers

•PAYX is the larger company ($36.05B vs $27.09B market cap).
•PAYX trades at the lower earnings multiple (22.21 vs 65.72 P/E).
•PAYX converts more revenue to profit (25.84% vs 9.26% net margin).
•PAYX grew revenue faster over the past five years (9.95% vs 8.60% CAGR).
•PAYX pays a dividend (4.40% yield) while ATI does not currently pay one.

Which is better, ATI or PAYX?

Metric tally: ATI 2 · PAYX 14

It depends on what you're optimizing for:

ValuePAYX(lower P/E)

GrowthPAYX(faster 5Y revenue CAGR)

QualityPAYX(higher ROIC)

Valuation

Metric	ATI	PAYX
P/E ratio	65.72	22.21●
Forward P/E	37.00	18.31●
P/S ratio	6.02	5.73●
P/B ratio	15.63	9.04●
PEG ratio	11.28	2.61●
EV / EBITDA	35.96	13.96●
FCF yield	2.00%	5.93%●

Profitability

Metric	ATI	PAYX
Gross margin	22.53%	73.93%●
Operating margin	14.47%	36.90%●
Net margin	9.26%	25.84%●
ROE	24.03%	40.78%●
ROIC	12.27%	16.77%●

Dividends

Metric	ATI	PAYX
Dividend yield	—	4.40%
Payout ratio	—	96.30%

Growth (annualized)

Metric	ATI	PAYX
Revenue CAGR (5Y)	8.60%	9.95%●
EPS CAGR (5Y)	6.43%	8.50%●
FCF CAGR (5Y)	73.92%●	13.61%
Total return CAGR (5Y)	52.80%●	2.18%

Frequently asked

Which is better, ATI or PAYX?: It depends on your goal. value: PAYX (lower P/E); growth: PAYX (faster 5Y revenue CAGR); quality: PAYX (higher ROIC). Across all compared metrics, PAYX leads 14 to 2.
Is ATI or PAYX cheaper?: On trailing earnings, PAYX is cheaper: ATI trades at a 65.72 P/E and PAYX at 22.21.
Which has grown faster, ATI or PAYX?: Over the past five years, PAYX grew revenue faster — ATI at a 8.60% CAGR versus PAYX at 9.95%.
Does ATI or PAYX pay a bigger dividend?: PAYX pays a dividend (4.40% yield) while ATI does not currently pay one.
Is ATI or PAYX more profitable?: PAYX runs the higher net margin — ATI at 9.26% versus PAYX at 25.84%.
Which has been the better investment, ATI or PAYX?: Over the past 10-year, ATI delivered the higher annualized total return — ATI at 30.94% versus PAYX at 9.63%. Past performance doesn't predict future results.

Go deeper

Full ATI analysis Full PAYX analysis Interactive comparison tool

Dig into the metrics

ATI P/E ratio Paychex P/E ratio ATI dividend yield Paychex dividend yield ATI ROE Paychex ROE ATI operating margin Paychex operating margin ATI revenue growth Paychex revenue growth ATI free cash flow Paychex free cash flow

ATI & Paychex appear in these rankings

Highest Dividend Yield Stocks Highest ROE Stocks Highest Operating Margin Stocks Highest FCF Yield Stocks

Figures are sourced from reported fundamentals and the latest end-of-day price. This comparison is informational only and is not investment advice. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology. Compiled by TGMCharts Research · data verified June 14, 2026.